Morgan Stanley (MS) & their local partner (Dyer & Blair) had sole rights to advertise and promote the SafCon OFS abroad. By bidding 5 cents, D&B became the Transaction Adviser (TA).
A conflict arose since the TA is also a stockbroker and placing agent. D&B advised that MS gets sole rights for foreign applicants. D&B then shares in the profits made by MS. So the 5 cents is elusive i.e. it cost Kenyans far more than 5 cents. it cost them billions!
MS could choose who they wanted to participate in the OFS. They could reject an application for any reason they deemed fit. They also could peek at the applications from other brokers thus allowing their clients (& themselves) to adjust the bids as needed.
Question: So what happened?
Answer: Well, MS picked applicants who were in their good books. This means THEIR clients who provide high-priced MS with business. Some of these applicants were 'connected' to the political establishment so while the ordinary Kenyan gets 30% of the application, MS+DB 'clients' could get 20%-35% unhindered!!!
MS could also buy for their own books meaning they reject valid applicants who offered more than 5.50 to leave the field clear for them.
Question: Why was 20-35% of a firm with 99.9% Kenyan subscribers & revenue being sold to foreigners who contribute little?
Answer: Well, it was a payback for political support. Coldtusker was NOT invited to participate! Many Kenyans would have willingly paid more than 5.50 ( including yours truly) for the 20-35% that was offered to the foreigners. It turns out there were applications/bids at 6.50 but 5.50 was chosen to benefit the so-called 'foreigners'. Therefore, at the MINIMUM, Kenyans lost (2bn shares x 1/-) KShs 2bn. The 1/- is what the real market would have paid above the 5.50 the GoK accepted.
If the allocation to foreigners was 35% then the loss could be KShs 3.5 bn.
Many Kenyans borrowed and had to pay upfront while the 'foreign' (in parentheses coz these foreigners were simply a front. There is NO scrutiny of they are!!!) applicants pay AFTER the allocation!
Equity was lending at 18% pa + 3% commitment fee.
10,000 shares@5 = 50,000. The issue closed on 23 April but refunds will be disbursed at the earliest on 10 Jun & clear 4-5 days later thus 60 days of interest on 50,000.
50,000 x 3% = 1,500
50,000 x 60/360 = 1,500 (Most banks use 360 days per year when charging interest)
allocation of 30% = 3,000 shares
Cost of 3,000 shares = 15,000 (for the shares) + 1,500 (Commitment Fee) + 1,500 (Interest) = 18,000
Cost per share = 18,000/3,000 = 6/-
The losses will run even higher than what I have shown above if the price of SafCon exceeds 6.50 per share - which is likely.
A pity but Kenyans continue getting screwed... royally screwed...
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Wednesday, May 07, 2008
Kenyans get royally SCREWED by Safaricom
Hear it here first!
Kenyans were taken for a ride by dyer & blair, morgan stanley, GoK crooks...
The foreigners - favoured by the idiots who set up the OFS- will pay KShs 5.50 for their shares!!! Yes, a mere 50 cents more than what wanjiku paid!
If I could get all the shares I wanted, I would have paid 6/-, let alone 5.50!!!!! So would have 1,000,000 other Kenyans.
I am pissed that the Kenyan government either got taken for a ride OR there was oddles of CORRUPTION.
Anybody interested in knowing how we got taken in?
Kenyans were taken for a ride by dyer & blair, morgan stanley, GoK crooks...
The foreigners - favoured by the idiots who set up the OFS- will pay KShs 5.50 for their shares!!! Yes, a mere 50 cents more than what wanjiku paid!
If I could get all the shares I wanted, I would have paid 6/-, let alone 5.50!!!!! So would have 1,000,000 other Kenyans.
I am pissed that the Kenyan government either got taken for a ride OR there was oddles of CORRUPTION.
Anybody interested in knowing how we got taken in?
Friday, May 02, 2008
Africa & the Wall Street Journal
The WSJ is taking a belated look at African stockmarkets.
Ryan Shen-Hoover (www.investinginafrica.net) has a paid - worth every penny - newsletter focused on listed firms on Sub-Saharan African stockmarkets. I have a subscription & have picked up a gem or two. If you contact him and say the magic words "I am an African investor and I read coldtusker's blog" he (might) give you a discount. No, he is not paying me but please sign up in droves so I can angle for a 'free' renewal. Please mention COLDTUSKER. You will need a Visa/Mastercard and its billed in US$. No, I will not lend you mine.
Subscribers also get access to hard-to-get financial reports for many listed African firms.
Anyway, here is the link to the WSJ blog.
Another firm highlighted in the blog - apart from Investing In Africa - is www.africanshareholder.com which has great info on African firms. Free. I would pay for it. Just don't tell them!
Ryan Shen-Hoover (www.investinginafrica.net) has a paid - worth every penny - newsletter focused on listed firms on Sub-Saharan African stockmarkets. I have a subscription & have picked up a gem or two. If you contact him and say the magic words "I am an African investor and I read coldtusker's blog" he (might) give you a discount. No, he is not paying me but please sign up in droves so I can angle for a 'free' renewal. Please mention COLDTUSKER. You will need a Visa/Mastercard and its billed in US$. No, I will not lend you mine.
Subscribers also get access to hard-to-get financial reports for many listed African firms.
Anyway, here is the link to the WSJ blog.
Another firm highlighted in the blog - apart from Investing In Africa - is www.africanshareholder.com which has great info on African firms. Free. I would pay for it. Just don't tell them!
Pluses & Minuses - Kenya's growing pains
NEGATIVE: The unaccountability of how tax revenue is spent continues unabated. Plastic manufacturers who pay 120% excise duty want to see the funds used to clean the environment. Makes sense but I think its being used to but new cars for the bloated cabinet!
POSITIVE: Another broker is licensed though not admitted to the NSE. We need more competition. Chartered Capital used to be Town & Country. CCL belongs to Chase Bank. James Gachui (of Trancentury) is a shareholder of Chase Bank.
NEGATIVE: Allegations of insider trading of Equity Bank shares.
POSITIVE: Kenya gets $10mn from EU to boost tourism. Of course, most of it will be spent in the EU promoting Kenya.
NEGATIVE: Nairobi's 'planning/zoning' is thrown out of the window as residential areas turn into commercial areas. Smells fishy to me. What say the Nairobi City Council?
POSITIVE: KCC is now profitable and likely to go public in 3-4 years.
POSITIVE: Another broker is licensed though not admitted to the NSE. We need more competition. Chartered Capital used to be Town & Country. CCL belongs to Chase Bank. James Gachui (of Trancentury) is a shareholder of Chase Bank.
NEGATIVE: Allegations of insider trading of Equity Bank shares.
POSITIVE: Kenya gets $10mn from EU to boost tourism. Of course, most of it will be spent in the EU promoting Kenya.
NEGATIVE: Nairobi's 'planning/zoning' is thrown out of the window as residential areas turn into commercial areas. Smells fishy to me. What say the Nairobi City Council?
POSITIVE: KCC is now profitable and likely to go public in 3-4 years.
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Disinvestment in Kenya
After the greedy, selfish & irresponsible actions by the politicians - PNU, ODM , ODM-K, NARC, etc - Kenyans are agitating for 'more'. The problem is that ALL the 'agitators' are government employees. So not only do we have the BLOATED cabinet, we have to pay more to civil servants.
So who suffers? The private sector who face tough trading conditions, poor infrastructure, insecurity & now have to contend with higher taxes. Nobody is paying attention to the vital industrial & agriculture sector on whom we rely on for real wealth creation.
Why are we surpirsed when many manufacturers relocate their factories to other countries, farmer abandon their crops, businesses default on loans and horticulture exporters move to Ethiopia?
Nurses give ultimatum to government
Teachers want higher salaries
Increased violent crime affecting businesspeople in Nairobi
Prison wardens strike for higher salaries and better conditions
Even the prisoners are on strike for higher pay!
Mungiki threat is killing the rural economy
So who suffers? The private sector who face tough trading conditions, poor infrastructure, insecurity & now have to contend with higher taxes. Nobody is paying attention to the vital industrial & agriculture sector on whom we rely on for real wealth creation.
Why are we surpirsed when many manufacturers relocate their factories to other countries, farmer abandon their crops, businesses default on loans and horticulture exporters move to Ethiopia?
Nurses give ultimatum to government
Teachers want higher salaries
Increased violent crime affecting businesspeople in Nairobi
Prison wardens strike for higher salaries and better conditions
Even the prisoners are on strike for higher pay!
Mungiki threat is killing the rural economy
Tuesday, April 29, 2008
Kenya needs to emulate India's dynamism...
I have said many times on my blog that Kenya needs to look to India for (positive) ideas & solutions on growth... Of course, we need to adapt these for Kenyan needs... and cut the corruption out!
Well Laila Macharia agrees... in her Business Daily article linked here...
Well Laila Macharia agrees... in her Business Daily article linked here...
Why is Kenyan labour costly vs Chinese labour?
China is growing in importance as a food exporter even with the recent 'food scares' in Japan and USA.
China has 1.2bn people but why is it that Kenya (a poor country with low 'cost' of living or low standards of living) can't compete with China?
Our flower, tea and horticulture exporters are crying over the strength of the KShs (vs the US$) while lamenting high costs of production,of which labour is a huge part, which makes them increasingly uncompetitive in world markets.
Why is Kenyan labour so expensive vis-a-vis China or India yet we have a (unofficial) 50% unemployment rate?
China has 1.2bn people but why is it that Kenya (a poor country with low 'cost' of living or low standards of living) can't compete with China?
Our flower, tea and horticulture exporters are crying over the strength of the KShs (vs the US$) while lamenting high costs of production,of which labour is a huge part, which makes them increasingly uncompetitive in world markets.
Why is Kenyan labour so expensive vis-a-vis China or India yet we have a (unofficial) 50% unemployment rate?
GoK spends & naps while Kenyans suffer...
Since Kenyans MPs earn huge salaries & perks ($180,000+) they do little but bicker in parliament while important economic matters are ignored.
Amos Kimunya plans to raise KShs 27bn (US$48mn) to fund extra expenditures. 70% of the funds will go for recurrent expenditure including OPERATING EXPENSES of the new ministries! Not for 'development'.
KPA needs $320mn to expand the port at Mombasa. The Japanese will loan them the money IF the GoK acts as a guarantor. The doubled capacity would enhance Mombasa's reputation as THE port in E & C Africa. It would create 1000s of jobs for Kenyans and earn Kenya additional forex.
Well, the parliament needs to approve the guarantee but, hey, they don't give two hoots. Why? They care more about a position in the bloated government rather than the country.
I think Kenyans are fools for electing these fools...
We need to get some serious lawmakers in parliament. Why do we have thugs, fossils, thieves and conmen as MPs? Because Kenyans elected most of them except those who rigged themselves in. I am ashamed that Kenya is being held back by the MPs we have.
We do have some bright sparks e.g. Martha Karua (I might not like her politics but she is a go-getter), James Orengo, Anyang Nyongo, Raila Odinga (when he stops politicking), Amos Kimunya (please STOP politicking!), etc. We need leadership from them. Now.
Amos Kimunya plans to raise KShs 27bn (US$48mn) to fund extra expenditures. 70% of the funds will go for recurrent expenditure including OPERATING EXPENSES of the new ministries! Not for 'development'.
KPA needs $320mn to expand the port at Mombasa. The Japanese will loan them the money IF the GoK acts as a guarantor. The doubled capacity would enhance Mombasa's reputation as THE port in E & C Africa. It would create 1000s of jobs for Kenyans and earn Kenya additional forex.
Well, the parliament needs to approve the guarantee but, hey, they don't give two hoots. Why? They care more about a position in the bloated government rather than the country.
I think Kenyans are fools for electing these fools...
We need to get some serious lawmakers in parliament. Why do we have thugs, fossils, thieves and conmen as MPs? Because Kenyans elected most of them except those who rigged themselves in. I am ashamed that Kenya is being held back by the MPs we have.
We do have some bright sparks e.g. Martha Karua (I might not like her politics but she is a go-getter), James Orengo, Anyang Nyongo, Raila Odinga (when he stops politicking), Amos Kimunya (please STOP politicking!), etc. We need leadership from them. Now.
A Tale of two(2) SafCon Prospectuses
Yes, it turns out that the GoK issued a 'revised' prospectus that most investors were unaware of. Does anyone know what the full extent of the 'changes' were?
The Safaricom OFS has been controversial from the beginning starting with the 35% allocation to foreigners to the Mobitelea's 'hidden' shareholders & stake.
The Safaricom OFS has been controversial from the beginning starting with the 35% allocation to foreigners to the Mobitelea's 'hidden' shareholders & stake.
Monday, April 28, 2008
Zimbabwean Follies... Worth a laugh!
Zimbabwe was a jewel in Africa but for the disregard of (just) law, bad politics and worse economics!
Minister for Agriculture Mechanization, Joseph Made, to a White farmer in recent times:
"Why do you white people always hide behind the law"
Then he goes on "We made the law we can change it"
Huh? JM, you idiot... it's the law! You made it and if you do not like it, change it! You are the government!
BTW, like Kenya there are superfluous ministries in Zimbabwe as well. There is a Minister for Agriculture as well, rugare gumbo. No wonder Africa is rich in resources but poor as hell in "wealth".
What next a Minister of Toilets - in charge of wiping mugabe's arse?
BTW, the Z$ is at Z$241mn vs US$1 (and the US$ has been tumbling of late).
Minister for Agriculture Mechanization, Joseph Made, to a White farmer in recent times:
"Why do you white people always hide behind the law"
Then he goes on "We made the law we can change it"
Huh? JM, you idiot... it's the law! You made it and if you do not like it, change it! You are the government!
BTW, like Kenya there are superfluous ministries in Zimbabwe as well. There is a Minister for Agriculture as well, rugare gumbo. No wonder Africa is rich in resources but poor as hell in "wealth".
What next a Minister of Toilets - in charge of wiping mugabe's arse?
BTW, the Z$ is at Z$241mn vs US$1 (and the US$ has been tumbling of late).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)