Blog Archive

Monday, February 26, 2007

Another Scandal - CMA, CDSC & NSE - The Unholy Trio

Many readers of this blog will have heard of the mess at the CDSC where some crooked/unethical brokers have been trading in shares that belonged to their clients.

Essentially, the brokers are selling client's shares without their knowledge! Even if the shares are "replaced" the clients/shareholders may not get dividends since the Listed Firm only recognises shares held by in the client's name.

Until this loophole is patched, all long-term investors should insist on share certificates to forestall the crooked stockbrokers' dealings. There are extra steps & it is not as convenient but safer.

With a certificate, you can use any broker without the hassle of transferring shares. You will need to "immobilise" & "dematerialise" the shares. Many of the large shareholders have NOT placed the shares with the CDSC.

Furthermore, except for fraud by having duplicate certificates, the share cannot be sold as (apparently) francis thuo & thieves did...

Who would you rank as the top 5 trustworthy brokers?

My list includes (in no particular order):
  • CFCFS
  • Kestrel
  • African Alliance

31 comments:

bankelele said...

I wonder how many people check their CDS statments (when they are mailed out).

regulator absent: I can't recall a single hot button issue in the last few years where CMA has commented. If it's not good news being announced, "it's no comment"

Anonymous said...

In the absense of an effective regulator, one should also consider taking legal action against the stock broker for losses arising from "illegal trades".

CT:
i'm seriously considering moving to African Alliance. I've had nothing but poor service from D & B.

Jakarumba said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

CT, very few brokers can ve trusted in the wake of new revelations. However I consider FD tristworthy.
Banks, CDSC is about technology, why shoul dwe wait for a month to get confirmation that all is well (remember you receive a statement only if you have had a transaction during that month)?
I think they need to come up with an online system where account holders can login and retrieve statements, this will in th long run cut postage costs.

Anonymous said...

As a one who has not invested but has been planning to invest on the NSE, the FT and now CDSC scandals have put me off. I think I will hold on and watch the situation before starting, especially since I'm abroad and may not be in a position to monitor my account as long as I cannot access it online. I may just settle for Unit Funds. By the way, CBA my present bank offers the CBA uNT FUNDS: Has any one got information on them before I make a buy (recommendation!).

Anonymous said...

Outfoxed, we seem to be on the same boat, But tell me something, how long does it take to actually switch from one broker to another?

I only have three weeks in Dec to pull it off. Do I have any realistic chance of achieving this?

Anonymous said...

Swaka:
It is actually a simple matter.
You fill "CDS form A "with your current broker and "CDS form B" with your new broker.

The problem is that your current broker has to submitt "form A" to your new broker and this is where they drag their feet.

I once changed brokers and it took me like 2 weeks.

MainaT said...

CT, have missed your posts.
CMA/NSE is a bit like wife and husband-who get along. Ntalaam and his broker gets suspended then CMA says, aah we got just the job for you, why don't you become our head.

Kestrel I like. I think you get what you pay for in this case, having to commit 500k+ to the NSE. The other suggestion is for guys especially the Diaspora to try nominee accounts with someone like CBA or Barclays.

coldtusker said...

Banks: CMA is pathetic esp for shareholder rights

Outfoxed & Swaka: Problem is that the current broker can delay the transfer by using all sorts of excuses! The holiday period tends to be slower than usual.

Jakarumba: CDSC system should allow online access.

MainaT: Custodial services are very expensive for smaller accounts.

MainaT said...

CT-Barclays charge 2% of the portfolio's value for anything upto a ksh1m. And they don't charge any addtional fee for the transactions.

coldtusker said...

MainaT: Pls provide additional details.

When you say no further transaction costs... does that include commissions.

Where can I get more info?

Who do I contact?

Anonymous said...

MainaT, CBA offers nominee a/c for retail customesr? All I am aware of is that they have started units funds but do not do any brokerage for small accounts!

MainaT said...

CT-sorry. been busy elsewhere-plse send me an at mainat@hotmail.com and i'll provide all the details.
Ruheni-i had an email response from CBA and likewise email me and I will reply

mwasjd said...

The CDS statement is usually 2 months behind schedule, needs to be more updated. I saw the CMA response in the paper, but didn't have any weight. They say that investors should sign purchase/sale orders before any execution, but I normally use email, so I wonder if I'm at risk of illegal trades in my account, even if I'm a small fry...

Anonymous said...

Mainat and co, why is this info secret? we are in a somewhat public forum so instead of sending secret emails to requestors, si you unleash all the info now? On a personal note, I have now been fleeced badly by Francis Drummond who sold my ICDC shares without my authorization as well as Dyer and Blair who refused to buy shares for me at my stated price insisting on me raising the price despite the fact that I could see the shares trading for almost 10 shillings less. This is only two weeks ago so am pretty mad at the whole system right now. I doubt there is any broker to be trusted but I guess I might as well make another one rich so if there are any recommended names, please let me know

Anonymous said...

Nice site, very informative. Plz check mine Online trading

Anonymous said...

Dear Visitors, This blog is really nice and informative. We are pleased to know this blog is really helping people. Its our pleasure to post informative content on this useful blog created by webmaster. Currently something is cooking in the Indian stock market, We know it but unfortunately we cant disclose the reason so openly. We strongly suggest everyone not to take any long position at these levels. We will see Pullback in the market very soon but that will be a fake one so don’t consider pullback as opportunity to go Long in market( Delivery based). As after that initial pullback we can see fall once again. As mentioned cant disclose it still giving minor hint see call and put section and think why you are not able to access few options and check December part and think who are the people behind it?? We suggest wait for falls to take delivery till then prefer only intraday else you will find yourself out of BSE and NSE one fine day. For any query feel free to contact us. Regards SHARETIPSINFO TEAM +91- 9891655316 +91- 9899056796 +91 - 9891890425

BUZZINGSTREET said...

Dear Visitor,
Market is showing some good move. Nifty traders are now confused if they should go short in Nifty from current level of 5400 or should go further long. NSE and BSE are the two major stock exchanges of Indian stock market. Keeping in mind that many investors and traders are very much confused with the current market move, we have stared posting " title="technical research reports"> technical research reports These reports are highly accurate and are available for free.

Regards
Stock market investment if done with proper research and updated knowledge than it can give very lucrative results. There are four basic golden rules of stock market which are to be followed. (thebuzzingstreet1@gmail.com)www.buzzingstreet.com


Nifty is on its peak now and is turning volatile. Investors are suggested to book long delivery positions soon. As after some more upmove we can see profit booking in the market soon. Investors are suggested to grab quality stocks at lower level again.

sharegyan001 said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading gyan

sharegyan001 said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading gyan

sharegyan001 said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading gyan

sharegyan001 said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading gyan

sharegyan001 said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading gyan

sharegyan001 said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading gyan

sharegyan001 said...

If you are trading in NSE, BSE, MCX and

in NCDEX then let sharegyan give you all stock trading

gyan

sharetipsinfo said...

In Indian stock market indexes are very important, now the question is what are indexes important? And what kind of averaging is done for calculation of an index. In stock market research and study pays in long term as it helps investors and day traders to determine value stocks. If investors or intraday traders are confused like where to invest they can take the advice from stock market consultant or stock market tips provider

sharemarketzone said...

It doesn’t matter if you are Share market trader or you started trading first time, you need to be very careful while trading. Many investors are not able to stay in profit for a long time because of the lack of trading knowledge. So let’s start discussion and see what everyone has to say about it.

Commodity Tips | Stock MarketTips said...

Now find all top Indian stock market analyst with their stock market
recommendations at one place

yanmaneee said...

coach outlet
jordans
cheap nfl jerseys
hermes handbags
adidas yeezy
coach outlet sale
nike air max 97
asics shoes
cheap jordans
balenciaga shoes

Best database provider said...


I appreciate your hard work. you have put to write such a wonderful article.
USA company Info database

Best call center services said...

Thanks for supporting your time to post such an interesting & useful content.Thank you so much, I appreciate your work.
data processing services